2025: The Year the Machine Started Eating Itself

This image was generated with RunwayML by Christine Greyson. Feel free to use it, and Happy New Year.

A Metal Musician's Guide to Surviving 2025 (and What's Coming in '26)

Let’s talk about what just happened. 2025 was the year the streaming empire finally showed its cracks—and for those of us who never fully bought into the playlist-industrial complex anyway, it was both validating and terrifying. The major labels spent the last decade telling us that "reach" was everything, that we needed to sand down our edges to fit algorithmic preferences, that metal was "too niche" for the modern streaming economy.

Turns out, they were selling us a bill of goods the whole time.

The 2% Rule: Or Why Your 47 Obsessive Fans Matter More Than Your 10,000 Casual Listeners

Here's the number that should matter to every musician reading this: super listeners—the people who actually give a shit about what you do—make up roughly 2% of an artist's audience but generate nearly 20% of streams and the overwhelming majority of actual revenue.

Think about that. The kid who buys your shirt at the merch table, streams your deep cuts, and drags their friends to your shows is worth more than a thousand people who heard you once on a "Power Metal Vibes" playlist and never thought about you again.

This year, the smart money finally figured out what DIY and underground artists have known forever: community beats reach every single time. Platforms like Vault.fm, Even, and FanCircles went from curiosities to necessities. Direct-to-fan subscription models stopped being a "side hustle" and became the main gig for bands who actually wanted to pay rent.

The math is brutal and beautiful: 500 fans paying you $10/month directly ($5,000/month, $60,000/year) versus 500,000 streams on Spotify (roughly $1,500–$2,000 if you're lucky). The old model was designed to make you feel small. The new one—if you can stomach the work—actually rewards the depth of connection you build.

For metal bands, this should feel familiar. We've always been a cult, not a trend. The difference now is that the infrastructure finally exists to monetize that cult properly.

Genre Is Dead. Long Live the Vibe.

Remember when someone would ask what kind of music you played and "thrash metal" or "doom" was a sufficient answer? That's over.

The algorithm doesn't care about your influences or your record collection. It cares about context. Music in 2025 is consumed based on utility and mood, not taxonomy. Playlists aren't called "Metal Classics" anymore—they're called "Rage Fuel" or "3AM Doomscroll."

This has created a weird opportunity: metal is showing up in places it never used to. A Meshuggah track on a workout playlist next to trap and EDM. Sleep's "Dopesmoker" on someone's "Focus Flow" mix. Black metal on a "Dark Academia" playlist alongside Chopin and synthwave.

The genre purists hate this. But if you can stomach your music being recontextualized, there's an opening here. Your audience isn't just metalheads anymore—it's anyone who needs what your music does. Aggression. Catharsis. Weight. Atmosphere.

The downside? Your music is competing with literally everything, all the time. The upside? You're no longer ghettoized into a "niche" that streaming services can underpay and ignore.

The Social Media Trap: How "Content Creation" Killed Creativity

Let's address the elephant in the mosh pit: social media didn't just change how music gets discovered—it fundamentally broke how artists create and exist.

2025 was the year we watched musicians stop being musicians and become content managers. The algorithmic demands are relentless: post three times a day, dance in front of your gear, film yourself "reacting" to your own songs, create 15-second hooks designed to stop the scroll, turn your creative process into performance, monetize your vulnerability, optimize your authenticity.

We saw bands that used to spend their time writing riffs instead spending it storyboarding TikToks. We watched artists have anxiety attacks over view counts and engagement metrics. We saw the creative process itself get warped—songs written with the "will this work on Reels?" filter applied before the first note was even recorded.

The "TikTok-ification" of music hit critical mass this year. Radio-friendly metal bands started front-loading their breakdowns to hit within three seconds. Legacy acts started releasing "TikTok edits" of classic tracks. Everyone became obsessed with the "hook moment" that would make their audio go viral.

For a genre built on the album experience, the 8-minute journey, the concept record—this isn't just annoying. It's existential poison.

Here's what nobody in the industry will admit: the social media game is designed to burn you out, not build you up. The algorithm doesn't care if you make great music. It cares if you make consistent, easily digestible content that keeps users scrolling. Those are fundamentally different goals, and they're often at war with each other.

The bands that "won" social media in 2025 weren't necessarily the ones making the best music—they were the ones willing to become full-time content farms. And here's the uncomfortable truth: for every artist who broke through, ten thousand others spent a year posting daily, got nowhere, and quit making music entirely because they were too exhausted from performing their own lives.

So here's the contrarian take that we're planting our flag on as we head into 2026:

Stop. Just stop.

Stop stressing about views. Stop panicking because your Reel only got 200 impressions. Stop reverse-engineering your art to appease an algorithm that will change next week anyway. Stop treating your creative life as a content pipeline.

Go back to what you actually love doing. Write the 12-minute song. Record the weird, unmarketable album. Spend six months in the woodshed getting your tone perfect instead of posting practice videos. Be bad at social media. Be inconsistent. Disappear for months while you actually create something worth sharing.

Your real audience—the 2% that actually matters—will catch up. They always do.

The greatest metal albums ever made weren't created by people worried about their engagement rate. Black Sabbath wasn't thinking about "content strategy." Neurosis didn't optimize for virality. Sleep didn't make Dopesmoker because it would perform well on TikTok—they made it because it's what they needed to create.

The bands that will still be around in ten years aren't the ones gaming the algorithm today. They're the ones making music so compelling that people seek it out despite the algorithm, music that spreads through actual human recommendation because it's too good to keep quiet about.

Does this mean ignore social media entirely? No. Use it when it serves you—share show dates, drop album announcements, connect with fans who want to connect back. But don't let it become your master. Don't let the tail wag the dog. And for the love of everything heavy, don't put all your eggs in the "social feed" basket, because that basket has a three-month shelf life before the platform changes the algorithm again and your reach disappears overnight.

Build your email list. Maintain your Bandcamp. Show up at the venues. Play the festivals. Talk to people in real life. Learn how to tag with metadata and secretly start “showing up online”. Create things that matter to you first, and trust that if it's good, if it's real, if it's necessary—the right people will find it.

The algorithm wants you anxious and constantly producing. Resist that. Make art instead of content. The difference might save your career, and more importantly, it might save why you started making music in the first place.

The Vinyl Paradox and the Resurrection of the CD

In the most beautifully contradictory trend of the year, physical media exploded—but not for the reasons anyone expected.

Vinyl sales grew for the 18th consecutive year, but why? Nearly half the people buying records this year don't own a turntable. The LP has become the ultimate piece of merchandise—a 12-inch poster you can hold, a totem of support, a way to say "I was here" in a culture where everything digital feels ephemeral.

For metal bands with killer album art (and let's be honest, that's most of you), this is a goldmine. Vinyl isn't a listening format anymore—it's a statement piece. Price it accordingly.

But the real resurrection? The CD.

Gen Z, priced out of the $35 vinyl market and drowning in Y2K nostalgia, rediscovered the jewel case. It's $10–$12, it's portable, no streaming service can delete it from your library, and it has that tactile, "ownable" quality that digital lacks. CD sales grew significantly in 2025, driven almost entirely by younger listeners who weren't even born when CDs were king.

If you're a touring band, this is your moment. A $10 CD at the merch table has a higher profit margin than almost anything else you're selling (yes, including that $25 shirt), and it's a low barrier for a fan who's on the fence about committing to vinyl.

The irony isn't lost on any of us: in the age of infinite digital access, people are buying plastic discs again. Turns out, ownership matters.

What 2026 Holds: The Return of the Human (Or: Why Your Weird Uncle Who Makes Mixtapes Is Suddenly Relevant Again)

So what's next?

If 2025 was about the fracture of the monoculture—the death of the "song everyone knows"—2026 will be about reconstruction. We're already seeing the early signs of what the industry is calling "algorithm fatigue." People are drowning in infinite choice, and the AI-curated playlists all sound the same.

Enter the tastemaker. Not the influencer—the curator. The person with actual taste, knowledge, and credibility. DJs. Newsletter writers. Record store clerks. Message board weirdos. The people who can cut through the noise because they actually care about the music, not the metrics.

For underground and independent metal, this is our natural habitat. We've always relied on word-of-mouth, zines, radio shows run by obsessives, and the recommendations of people who've earned our trust. The mainstream is just now realizing what they lost when they outsourced curation to the algorithm.

If you're a musician, this means a few things:

Build actual relationships. Not follower counts—relationships. With other bands, with venues, with the people who run blogs and podcasts and college radio stations. The gatekeepers are dead, but the guides are coming back.

Invest in your direct channels. Email lists, Patreon, Bandcamp, Discord servers—whatever lets you talk to your people without a platform playing middleman. The algorithm is unreliable. Your fans' inboxes are forever.

Stop chasing virality. It's a lottery, and the house always wins. Chase depth instead. A hundred people who will drive two hours to see you play are worth more than a million passive streams. Build for the 2%, not the 98%.

Embrace the weird. The monoculture is dead, and that means there's no "correct" way to do this anymore. The bands that will thrive in 2026 are the ones willing to experiment, to be strange, to double down on what makes them different rather than sanding off edges to chase playlists that don't care about them anyway.

Final Thoughts: We've Been Here Before

And here it is: for those of us in metal, punk, hardcore, and the various other subgenres that never got the Spotify money anyway, 2025 wasn't a revolution—it was the rest of the industry finally catching up to where we've always been.

We've always been too loud, too weird, too long, too aggressive for the algorithm. We've always relied on true believers and cult followings. We've always sold physical media at shows and built community through shared obsession rather than passive consumption.

The difference now is that the infrastructure exists to actually make a living this way, and the culture is shifting back toward valuing what we've always valued: authenticity, commitment, and depth over breadth.

So as you ring in 2026, don't think of this as adapting to a new landscape. Think of it as the landscape finally adapting to us.

The machine is eating itself. Let it. We'll still be here when the dust settles, doing what we've always done: playing too loud, caring too much, and building something real in a world that increasingly feels fake.

Happy New Year. Now go make something heavy.